The response to last night's episode seems to be mixed. More positive than negative, from what I've read, but people either hated it or they loved it. As for myself, I loved it. If this is the kind of story and flashback that every character will have this season, I think it will be the best overall. The first six episodes (the fall pod) were good but they weren't up to LOST standards. But these last two (last week's and this week's) were great, in my opinion. Action and weirdness in last week's, storytelling and deep weirdness in this week's. Anyways, let's get to the observations...
**edit 6:20PM: after watching the episode again, I added two observations and more screenshots
1) One of the big questions: Is Desmond seeing the future or re-living the past? How does it work? Is real time paused when he re-lives the past? Is he really just delaying fate's course by saving Charlie or is he changing Charlie's destiny? Some deep theories abound but I don't think it's time to figure that out yet.
2) Another big question: Is Charlie doomed to die? I think that would be too easy and expected. Usually the deaths are more unexpected (unless they're spoiled as I've read Shannon's death was last season). Perhaps this is a test for Desmond. Maybe he can really amount to something great by saving lives instead of just postponing death.
3) Didn't notice this but one commenter on USA Today found that Charlie's lyrics outside of the Widmore building were "I said maybe / You're gonna be the one that saves me..". While I think it's just an Easter egg, I thought it was interesting.
4) In the flashback, Penny asks "Where are you?". In the context of the flashback, this meant "What are you thinking? How are you?" but perhaps, Penny has lived the moment before and was asking the location of the island. Unlikely, yes, but possible.
5) Is Desmond's flashback to re-living the past tied to his experience in the hatch. "They" (whoever) told Desmond to push the button, save the world. It's all you'll ever be good for. Don't try to change the future, that's futile because "we" say so. Is this a big Dharma experiment?
6) What does Desmond walking past the military recruitment office mean? In a previous flashback (season 2 finale), he was in the military and was dishonorably discharged. Does his walking by mean that in the "new" past, he doesn't join the service?
7) Has Desmond possibly gone back to the past and told Penny that he was on an island with a large electromagnetic anomaly? How else would she know to look for electromagnetic anomalies?
8) The lady in the flashback (who knew the future too, perhaps Desmond's sub-conscious?) pointed out the red shoes. Perhaps this is another reference to the Wizard of Oz (like Ben's fake name: Henry Gale). In the Wizard of Oz, it was all a dream. Perhaps Desmond's post-hatch flashbacks is all a dream too.
9) Did you notice the painting in Mr. Widmore's office? The screenshot is to the left (click for full resolution). Notice the letters at the top reversed spell "Namaste", the greeting used by the Dharma Initiative in their hatch orientation. There's a polar bear, a skeleton, and mountains. Reminds me of the episode earlier this season where Locke is in the cave trying to find Mr. Eko. Any significance? (Click here for more screenshots, including the close-up shot of the painting)
10) After the photo was taken in the flashback, when Desmond is breaking up with Penny, she says "don't try to rewrite the future". I don't know how I missed it yesterday but perhaps, she has seen the future and is re-living the past too?
11) What exactly did the hatch do? I think it was Locke who said it imploded but how do things get out of the hatch if it imploded (it would have to explode)? Maybe it exploded then imploded within seconds? How did the door get blown onto the beach in last season's finale if it just imploded?
You can see more screenshots I took on Flickr, click here
If you missed last night's episode or want to see it again, you can watch it for free at ABC.com or you can buy it to watch anytime on your computer or iPod on iTunes.
For MSNBC's "Revelations", click here.
Got something to say? Comment below.